Manifesto

Five minutes to read. Nothing withheld at source.

“Poor, wretched, and stupid peoples, nations determined on your ill, blind to your own good! You let yourselves be deprived before your own eyes of the best part of your revenues; your fields are plundered, your homes robbed and stripped. You live in such a way that nothing is yours any more.”

Étienne de La Boétie, Discourse on Voluntary Servitude, 1576. He was eighteen.

I. Nobody asked for your opinion

Every month, before you have even touched your money, someone has helped himself. And not a little: add up what is withheld from your salary, what is added to the price of everything you buy, the weight of regulations, artificial monopolies and the absence of competition, not to mention what is levied on everything you already own, and three quarters of what you produce is taken from you by force. And more than half of what you produce never comes back to you as a service. If your neighbour did this, you would call the police. When the State does it, with the police behind it, you call it civilisation. We do not think you are stupid. We think you have been well brought up. By the system. Knock knock. Wake up, Neo.

What sets the State apart from every other human organisation? Not its size, not its flag, not its good intentions. There are only two ways to get what you want: earn it, by producing or trading, or take it from the person who earned it. The baker, the insurer, the football club must convince you before they get your money. The State is the only one that gets it by force, and the only one allowed to. Any organisation that lives by plunder and forbids, on its territory, anyone to compete with it, is a mafia. This one has simply done better than the others: it has convinced its victims that it protects them. The highwayman, at least, has the honesty not to come back the following year and sweetly call you “taxpayer”.

For this to hold, you need a fiction that gathers and unites, and this one has a name: the State. It is, in truth, the great fiction through which everybody endeavours to live at the expense of everybody else. Everyone hopes to receive more than he gives. Since that is impossible for everyone at once, everyone ends up paying, obviously, with the useless commission of the predatory middleman on top. The fiction holds because people are paid with the stolen money to teach that without it there would be chaos: teachers in a monopoly position (state education), intellectuals stuffed with public money, subsidised media in the most collectivist countries, and so on. Nobody has any interest in developing an independent intellectual critique if that means cutting off the hand that feeds.

II. And the shoes?

A kid breaks the baker’s shop window. The onlookers, furious at first, console themselves: the glazier will have work, he will spend that money in turn, money circulates, misfortune keeps trade going. That is what is seen. What is not seen is the pair of shoes the baker will now never be able to afford. What the glazier gains, the cobbler loses. And society as a whole is deprived of a pair of shoes. Without the kid, the village had a shop window and a pair of shoes. With him, it has only the window. Every public expenditure is this illusion made real. You are shown the bridge, the stadium, the subsidised job, the benefit paid out. You are never shown what would have been done with that money had it been left to the people who earned it.

The whole difference between the bad economist and the good one lies there. The bad one looks only at the immediate effect of a measure, on the group it is meant to help. The good one traces its long-term effects, on all groups, including those who pay without knowing it. The bad economist always has a ribbon to cut; the good one always has bad news. The whole art of the statesman consists in showing you only the new window. The whole art of the free man consists in asking: and the shoes?

But suppose an honest statesman, one who looked at both sides of the ledger before spending. He would still be blind, and here is why. How many bakeries does a town need? Nobody knows, and yet there are roughly the right number. No office decided it: prices said so. A rent that rises, a flour price that falls, a customer who goes next door: each signal sums up what thousands of people know and want, and what nobody could ever inventory. Prices are the only language in which an entire society tells itself what is scarce and what is plentiful. Abolish property and you abolish exchange; abolish exchange and you abolish prices; without prices, the most sincere planner no longer knows whether he is creating value or destroying it. He is blind, and he is at the wheel. That is why planned economies lack not only bread, but also the information that would warn that bread is about to run out. An economy is not a machine to be tuned. It is millions of people acting, each for their own reasons, and human action cannot be decreed.

III. Voting is not consenting

We are told: but this is democracy, you voted. Look at what an executive does when he is paid on short-term results but has no real stake in the company: he can sell the machines, cut everything that will only pay off in ten years, and still leave with his bonus. The elected official is that executive. He does not own a single share of the country, he has five years, and the bill arrives after he has gone. Democracy did not abolish the predation of the kings of old. It made it rotate, and “respectable” because it became habitual. As for consent: choosing every five years which brigand will be entitled to rob you is not consenting to be robbed. You are allowed to choose your masters, and you should not be content with that.

And when the visible tax is no longer enough, there remains the one nobody votes on. Step 1: impose the use of a “currency” on pain of a fine, legal tender. Step 2: create money at will, for yourself and your friends. That is inflation. When money is created at will, the loaf of bread does not become more expensive: it is the euro that is worth less over time. But not everyone finds out at the same time. The new money first reaches the pockets of those closest to the tap, the State, the banks, the friends of power, who still spend at the old prices and grab the scarce goods that are hard to produce (shares, property, land), driving their prices up as they go. It reaches the wage earner and the saver last, and they pay the new prices with money that has already lost its value. That is the Cantillon effect: a silent transfer from the last served to the first. And it does not only ruin accounts; it ruins incentives and corrupts behaviour. Money that melts punishes the saver, lowers the opportunity cost for the overspender, and even rewards the borrower; it teaches an entire society to think about the present rather than the future. Civilisation is exactly the opposite: the ability to think in the long term.

IV. Never initiate violence

What, then, do we stand for? One rule, a single one, which you already apply naturally with your family, your friends, your neighbours: nobody has the right to use force against the person or property of another. Defending yourself, yes. Striking first, never. That is the non-aggression principle, and it admits no exception, not for majorities, not for uniforms, not for good causes.

To judge a law, look at whether it takes from some what belongs to them in order to give it to others. If it does, it is plunder, and the fact that it is legal makes it no less illegitimate. The law should only protect the person and property. Perverted, it becomes the surest instrument for violating them, by disarming the victim in the name of justice. Put any law to this test. The one that passes is legitimate. The one that fails is an aggression justified by headed notepaper.

Note, moreover, that private property is not defined arbitrarily. It precedes any institution that would seek to preserve or regulate it, and it emerges spontaneously from the will of individuals to live together. To form a society, one must organise, negotiate, agree on the terms of living together. In doing so, we implicitly admit that our intention is not predation, since negotiation and predation are antithetical. Thus we recognise, as a matter of fact, our neighbour’s right to dispose of his own body. Property is therefore born of the desire to live together and of our renunciation of fighting to settle our disputes.

Property does exist independently of institutions, and is a precondition for their existence. Arguing against this fact is in itself a performative contradiction since, as we have just seen, to argue is to recognise private property. Furthermore, from ownership of one’s own body follows logically the ownership of the things that allow us to preserve our integrity. The means put to work by a human being who acts to protect himself from hunger, thirst, cold and the unknown become, as a matter of fact, legitimate property, as long as they do not encroach on the property of others, obviously. Any doctrine that justifies coercion and plunder encroaches, as a matter of fact, on the right to self-ownership, and falls back into performative contradiction.

V. The tyrant has only the strength we lend him

If all this is true, why does it go on? The author of our epigraph answered four and a half centuries ago: the tyrant has no power but the power you give him. No army is large enough to hold a people that refuses. Servitude is voluntary. It holds through habit, through the small favours handed out to those who serve, through the fear of being the first to stand up. There is no need to overthrow anything. It is enough to stop supporting it, to stop pretending to believe in it, and to say so out loud. On a wall, in a conversation, on a t-shirt. The author of our epigraph promised as much: support him no longer, and you will see him, like a great colossus whose base has been broken, collapse under his own weight and shatter.

And the poor, and security, and the roads? None of the three requires a monopoly. The roads first, since that is the favourite objection: the State does not build them, it orders them. The motorways, bridges and tunnels presented to you as public works are, more often than not, concessions: the State signs, a private company finances, builds and operates. What the State concedes, an association of owners, residents or shopkeepers could just as well commission itself, without the commission. Security is a service; entrusted to a monopoly, it has the flaws of every monopoly: expensive, mediocre, contemptuous of the customer. As for solidarity, it needs no policeman. Before the State seized it, workers across Europe insured one another in mutual aid societies, hospitals were born of bequests, schools of subscriptions. Giving and gift are an economy in their own right, older than the State and smothered by it: every euro taken by force is a euro that will not be given freely, and the welfare state has replaced charity with the queue, and gratitude with resentment. Solidarity cannot be decreed and cannot be levied. It exists as soon as people are left with something to give, and the choice to give it.

We follow this logic to the end. Property exists because things are scarce: two people cannot wear the same shirt at the same time. An idea, on the other hand, can be copied without depriving anyone of it. “Intellectual property” is therefore not property; it is a monopoly granted by the State over what others are allowed to do with their own ink and their own cloth. The designs on this site are free. Copy them, wear them, improve them. If you would rather buy them from us, it is because you want to, and that is the only good reason to buy anything.

VI. The future is not on their side

The State as we know it is a product of the industrial age. Wealth then was physical, immobile and easy to count, hence easy to tax: a factory does not move overnight. Knowledge, software, an encrypted account, a currency that nobody issues move in a second. As wealth turns into information, the returns on coercion fall: you cannot seize what you cannot see, you cannot hold what can leave. States will have to compete to keep their inhabitants, as any supplier keeps its customers. We do not predict the end of the State. We observe that its model, taking from those who cannot leave, loses captive customers every year. And that the choice to stop being captive is, for the first time, within everyone’s reach.

VII. No more taboos

Against coercion, against violence, against legal monopolies, whatever the colour of the flag planted on top of them. For the freedom of each, voluntary exchange, self-ownership, sound money, generosity and real solidarity, the kind that is given.

There is what you are allowed to say in public without being taken for a madman, and what you keep to yourself. That line is not fixed: it moves back because people say, repeat and own what was forbidden the day before. Saying that taxation is theft used to mark you as a crank; today, you wear it on a t-shirt. So, no more taboos. Taxation is theft. The State is a mafia that made it. Consent does not come in variable geometry: what you would not accept from a neighbour, you do not accept from a uniform. You have the right to say no, and the duty to say it out loud.

That is what these clothes are for. Every t-shirt is one more sentence in the street, one more conversation at the café, one more idea nobody is ashamed to say any more. Wearing the colours of liberty is not a fashion statement; it is a stand that asks nobody’s permission. Every piece sold funds the next one, and the next one will go further. So that one day, four and a half centuries on, La Boétie is finally heard.

Further reading, to check for yourself

Fancy Gulag — Doing time in style

Navigation

Order of the Iron Curtain

Order of the Iron Curtain

Members get nothing. Join anyway.

Fancy Gulag — est. by the State